![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
johncomicApparently Lily Allen has recently goosed a new spate of activity in the debate re file-sharing, artistic copyright, etc. I'm sure I have posted about this before but can't lay my hands on it now, so I'll weigh in yet again with my $0.03 CAN:
If I am, say, a professional musician, that means I am trying to earn a living by making music. Part of how I do that is by selling recordings of my music. If you obtain a recording of my music without paying me for it, you are depriving me of a portion of my livelihood. Basically, you are saying that you are entitled to decide “how much money I am allowed to make at my job”. [I've actually heard people argue that so-and-so “has already earned enough, they don't need any more”...] Or, you're telling me that I have no right to expect to be able to make a living this way.
Yet if I, the professional musician, were to take it upon myself to decide how much money you are allowed to earn, and I actually had the power to do something about it, how would you feel about that? You OK with it? Or are you merely OK with the idea of you being able to screw over an artist in a way that you yourself wouldn't wanna be screwed over?
If I am, say, a professional musician, that means I am trying to earn a living by making music. Part of how I do that is by selling recordings of my music. If you obtain a recording of my music without paying me for it, you are depriving me of a portion of my livelihood. Basically, you are saying that you are entitled to decide “how much money I am allowed to make at my job”. [I've actually heard people argue that so-and-so “has already earned enough, they don't need any more”...] Or, you're telling me that I have no right to expect to be able to make a living this way.
Yet if I, the professional musician, were to take it upon myself to decide how much money you are allowed to earn, and I actually had the power to do something about it, how would you feel about that? You OK with it? Or are you merely OK with the idea of you being able to screw over an artist in a way that you yourself wouldn't wanna be screwed over?
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-09-24 06:19 pm (UTC)True enough. I realize that the gist of my argument is that this activity is morally wrong, if not morally indefensible. I don't expect such an argument to sway anyone, I'm just stating my own position. Anyone who actually gives an excrement about the moral aspect of it, will heed the dictates of their own moral compass, not mine....